Andor's Trail

While fighting on the blackwater mountain you come across this extremely rare "blackwater brew" that looks different, you ask the potion maker in prim or blackwater and they say it smells like rat poison, they say u should throw it away. But you bring it to that small group of rat poison addicted people. you find two tooth and give him it. It destroies his addiction. He then tells you he used to be a blackwater blacksmith(thats why the blackwater brew cleared him). His specialty was spells on weapons, he then says if I ever find any blackwater weapons he can add/remove certain spells on certain weapons:D just an idea

That's a sweet idea. The Blackwater Sword and Dagger would be deadly without Blackwater Misery on them.

+100 Sounds good!
I'm gonna bring it up in the meeting!

BW weapons are darn powerful w/o misery.
Bye-bye QSD.

So I've been thinking on this quest idea some more and realized there were some plot flaws so I came up with the fix, once you find the bw brew you can only take it to prim (black water potion maker would say there is nothing is wrong with it) but the prim potion maker says it is rat poison. With two tooth, after he has tasted the brew and become clean, he sends you to bw to "get his equipment" (more brew), here is the biggest change, he will give you papers to become a bw resident (because some of us killed the battle master and are hated by bw) but now we can buy and sell there. You bring two tooth more brew and the quest continues as before.

There's another flaw. Some of us sided with bws and the potion maker doesn't want anything to do with us.

So it must be able to go through with both sides either or, with slight variations pending which side of the story u chose.

Do not allow players to have access to both cities, instead have the potionmaker mock you but only help you because two tooth is his old friend/cousin or something.

So two tooth was born in prim but moved to bw to start business when prim kicked him out for his dark magic, that way if u go with prim the family member is the potion maker and has pity on his story, and if u walk with bw the potion maker helps you out of respect for two tooth's magic?

Pk is right.